"Double Standard": Former Professor Sparks Outrage After Criticizing Grieving Family in Okinawa Boat Tragedy

A former Doshisha University Graduate School professor, Kenichi Asano, has ignited a fierce debate on social media over remarks directed at the bereaved family of a female university student who died in a boat capsizing accident off Henoko, Nago City, Okinawa. Asano suggested that "even parents and children are separate individuals, and parents should not speak for their deceased daughter."

Asano’s comments were aimed at the family’s continued efforts on social media and the blogging platform Note to uncover the truth behind the accident and criticize the university's response. According to reports from Sankei News and other outlets, Asano also stated, "The deceased student likely would not have wanted to see this kind of bashing directed at Doshisha."

In response, social media users have slammed Asano for what they call a blatant "double standard." Many pointed out a contradiction: while Asano has previously praised activists who claim to hear "voices from heaven" encouraging them to continue protests, he is now attempting to silence actual parents by citing "separate identities." Angry comments have flooded the internet, with users asking, "Why is it acceptable for an unrelated activist to speak for someone, but not the actual family?" and calling his words "cruel remarks that completely disregard the feelings of the bereaved."

There is also growing concern that the phrase "separate individuals" is being weaponized to muzzle the family. Critics argue that "precisely because they are separate individuals, the surviving family has the right to speak out to protect the honor and facts surrounding the deceased." Many are also questioning Asano's morality as an educator.

For a family who suddenly lost a loved one, their public messaging is rooted in a desperate desire to reveal the facts. The former professor's critical stance is being viewed as an act that further traumatizes the grieving family. With some internet users describing his behavior as "inhumane," the controversy shows no signs of slowing down.

The context

In April 2024, a boat belonging to a Doshisha University club capsized during an outing off the coast of Henoko in Nago City, Okinawa, resulting in the tragic death of a female student. Since the incident, the victim's family has been vocal on social media, expressing frustration with the university's perceived lack of accountability and seeking a thorough investigation. Kenichi Asano, the professor at the center of this controversy, is a former journalism professor known for his outspoken views on media ethics, but his latest remarks have drawn widespread condemnation for their perceived lack of empathy toward the victims.